The National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 has started new discussions about the three-language rule, especially between the central government and Tamil Nadu. This debate goes back to the 1960s, when Tamil Nadu strongly opposed making Hindi a required language in schools. While the central government supports the policy to promote learning multiple languages, Tamil Nadu believes it puts too much pressure on states that don’t speak Hindi.
What is the Three-Language Rule?
The three-language rule was first suggested by the Kothari Commission, which studied education in India from 1964 to 1966. It became part of the National Policy on Education (NPE) in 1968, during Indira Gandhi’s time as Prime Minister. This rule aimed to help students learn three languages:
1. Their mother tongue or regional language.
2. The official language of India (Hindi).
3. A modern Indian or European language.
In areas where Hindi is the common language, schools were advised to teach a modern Indian language from the south. In states where Hindi is not spoken as much, students were to learn Hindi, their regional language, and English. This idea was repeated in later versions of the policy in 1986 and 1992, which talked about the importance of Hindi as a common link language for the nation.
Is Hindi Being Forced by NEP 2020?
The central government says NEP 2020 is more relaxed about language learning, stating, “We will keep the three-language formula but let states, regions, and students choose their languages.” The new policy ensures that while it encourages learning different languages, states can decide what languages to teach, as long as at least two of the three languages are native to India.
Why is Learning in Your Own Language Important?
NEP 2020 believes that learning in your own language helps students understand better and keeps cultural traditions alive. Studies, including one by UNESCO, show that children learn faster and grasp important concepts in their mother tongue.
Support from National Curriculum Framework
The National Curriculum Framework has always supported the three-language rule. In its latest version (2023), it emphasizes that this rule should continue for the same reasons: respecting the Constitution, promoting different languages, and ensuring national unity.
Tamil Nadu’s Stand Against the Policy
Tamil Nadu has a long history of resisting the three-language rule. In 1937, the then-Congress government tried to make Hindi compulsory in schools, which led to protests by local leaders. Although that rule was canceled, the feelings against Hindi continued.
When the three-language rule was introduced in 1968, Tamil Nadu rejected it, believing it aimed to impose Hindi on them. Under Chief Minister C. N. Annadurai, the state decided to teach only Tamil and English, becoming the only state that has not followed the three-language guideline.
Funding Controversy and More Issues
Because Tamil Nadu refuses to accept important parts of NEP 2020, especially the three-language rule, the central government has stopped giving Rs 573 crore in educational help. According to policy rules, states need to follow NEP guidelines to receive this funding, which is crucial for education.
The Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan, started in 2018, has been improved under NEP 2020, focusing on better learning and literacy. Different states receive different funding levels based on their needs.